Quote:
Originally Posted by tvmanismadformad
It only counts if they appear as the character in costume. I'm willing to give way on some stuff but on this I'm not.
|
Ah, but can you honestly argue Carlie putting on a wig and saying in her normal voice, "Hi, I'm Megyn Kelly!" is more of an impression than Piotr doing three perfect, bang-on seconds of Ian McKellen? If Ian McKellen doesn't count, a good two thirds of the "impressions" that
were listed shouldn't count either.
Quote:
|
Dora is animated, but Michelle is playing Dora as a live action person, so it totally counts as an impression.
|
I get it. Just noting that it feels weird.
Quote:
|
I agree that it feels a little wrong to include that as part of these categories, but my response to this is two fold. One, HBO First Look really does feel like a commercial on HBO and since it can be 15 minutes long it feels like a tv show. Second, as you said somewhere in here, there were only 9 episodes this season. You need a little inflation of things in order get a full field of choices.
|
Fair enough. Again, more a matter of pointing out the weirdness than a complaint. I don't mind getting to vote for that sketch twice.
Quote:
|
If you feel there should be individual character nominations, I am open to splitting this section apart into people, not just individual sketches.
|
I think the way you have it is fine -- just add Safe Space to the list of options. And Jeff Goldblum to the commercial list.